ESG Reporting Doesn’t Always Boost Value
A new study from the Centre for Governance and Sustainability at NUS Business School has uncovered an unexpected trend. In the palm oil industry, companies that openly report their environmental, social, and governance (ESG) efforts may actually face lower valuations. This goes against what’s seen in most other industries, where better ESG reporting usually attracts more investor interest.
Researchers looked at 36 palm oil firms that are listed on stock exchanges. These companies were mostly based in Malaysia and Indonesia. Both countries are major players in global palm oil production. The study used a detailed toolkit with 182 indicators to rate how clearly each company shared their ESG activities.
Interestingly, firms with better ESG transparency were valued lower than those with less detailed reporting. This was measured using the price-to-earnings ratio—a key way investors judge a company’s worth.
High ESG Risk Affects Investor Confidence
One of the biggest reasons behind this trend is the palm oil industry’s link with high ESG risks. These include deforestation, poor labor conditions, and land-use conflicts. Over time, such issues have made investors cautious about the sector, even if a company tries to do better.
When a palm oil company is more transparent about its ESG efforts, it may be highlighting problems rather than reassuring investors. This can make the company appear riskier. As a result, investors may back away, fearing long-term costs and regulatory challenges.
The study found that this negative relationship between ESG scores and company valuation is unique to the palm oil industry. Therefore, In most other sectors, being open about sustainability usually increases trust and boosts stock prices.
Technology Can Help Small Firms Catch Up
Many smaller palm oil firms struggle with ESG reporting. They may not have the right tools or resources to show how they are working toward sustainability. This puts them at a disadvantage.
Enhancing Transparency: PwC and Google Cloud’s Tax Compliance Innovation
However, new technology can make a big difference. Digital tools and software can help these companies collect, organize, and present ESG data more easily. Better reporting tools could reduce the cost and effort needed to meet investor and policy expectations.
Even so, detailed ESG reporting doesn’t always lead to better valuations in this industry. Many investors remain focused on the risks. This makes it hard for even well-intentioned firms to gain financial rewards for being transparent.
Role of Policies and Stakeholders in Driving Change
The study highlights the important role of government policies in shaping investor behavior. Countries that produce and import palm oil can create laws that reward sustainable practices. These laws can push companies to improve without fearing financial losses.
At the same time, all stakeholders must play a part. This includes investors, regulators, and companies themselves. When they work together, they can change how the sector is viewed. Companies also need to explain their ESG efforts clearly to the public.
Clear communication can help fight negative perceptions. It can show that a company is serious about protecting the environment and supporting workers. This may help build trust over time, even if it doesn’t show up in valuations right away.
This surprising trend in the palm oil industry shows that being transparent about ESG efforts can lead to lower company valuations. The industry’s history of environmental and social issues weighs heavily on investor decisions. Hence, as firms try to do the right thing, they may be seen as risky. With most firms based in Malaysia and Indonesia, any change in public and investor opinion will require strong action from all sides.
 efforts may actually face lower){kind=link}